Earnings quality research: Advances, challenges and future research☆
Introduction
Dechow, Ge and Schrand (2010) (DGS) provides a comprehensive and detailed review of the earnings quality (EQ) research and contains numerous penetrating insights. The literature discussed in the review spans several decades, covering nearly 350 studies in more than a dozen topical areas. A distinctive feature of the review is that it includes an in-depth discussion of issues related to the convergent and divergent validity of the proxies most commonly used in the EQ literature. This approach is original to the literature and significantly enhances our understanding of issues related to EQ. DGS is ambitious and exhaustive, and succeeds in providing an excellent overview and critique of the EQ literature.
The purpose of this discussion is to offer a few additional observations on the EQ literature and to comment on some of DGS’s major conclusions. My remarks are not intended to be comprehensive but instead are limited to issues in the literature that I find particularly significant.
Section 2 begins with some conjectures about why the EQ literature has grown so rapidly over the past two decades and Section 3 discusses some of the literature’s important accomplishments. Section 4 notes several challenges researchers in the area face and Section 5 speculates on potential directions for future research. Section 6 discusses some of the difficulties inherent in reviewing such a broad literature and comments on DGS’s conclusions. Section 7 summarizes my observations.
Section snippets
Growth in the EQ literature
Research on EQ has grown dramatically over the past two decades. This is particularly true in the earnings management area, which comprises the majority of studies reviewed by DGS. While speculative, I believe the major drivers of the growth in the EQ area are likely to be the confluence of several factors that have both encouraged and facilitated this line of research. A factor encouraging this research was the SEC’s harsh allegations during the 1990s of widespread earnings management among
Progression of and accomplishments in the EQ literature
As it has expanded, the EQ literature has improved on several dimensions. One of the most dramatic improvements has been in the rigor of the EQ proxies, particularly the proxies measuring abnormal accruals. Abnormal accruals is by far the single most popular proxy used in the papers reviewed in DGS and a hallmark of the EQ research is the nearly continual innovations made to these proxies. Indeed, the measure used in the earliest study that employs abnormal accruals as a proxy (Healy, 1985),
Challenges in the EQ literature
While I think that the literature has made important advances, I also think there are many challenges in studying EQ. One is that all of our abnormal accruals models suffer from the inherent limitation that we are unable to validate the accuracy of their predictions. For example, we are unable to verify whether our estimates of discretionary accruals are the result of management’s opportunistic accounting choices, or just an artifact of the particular model we are using. This is a construct
Future directions for EQ research
Going forward, I think there are accounting developments on the horizon about which we know relatively little, and hence are logical prospects for future research. One example is fair-value accounting, which represents a potentially sea-changing development in the accounting environment. Fair-value accounting essentially follows from the explicit rejection of the concept of conservatism by standard setters in the newly proposed conceptual framework for financial reporting (IASB, 2008). Changing
Comments on DGS
DGS organizes their review around critiquing the construct validity of the proxies used in the EQ literature. As DGS acknowledges, however, EQ is not well defined in the accounting literature and has come to represent different concepts across the studies that employ this term. While the authors attempt to capture a commonality by using the definition of EQ provided in Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts (SFAC) No. 1, this definition is quite broad. As a result, the EQ studies evaluated
Summary
This discussion provides several observations on the EQ literature reviewed in DGS and comments on DGS’s major conclusions. I conjecture that key factors responsible for the large growth in EQ literature over the past two decades include the SEC’s harsh allegations of widespread earnings management by public companies, the literature’s adoption of the Jones model as a more-or-less generally accepted proxy for EQ, and the development and implementation of a set of internationally accepted
References (63)
- et al.
Earnings quality in UK private firms: comparative loss recognition timeliness
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(2005) - et al.
The effect of international institutional factors on properties of accounting earnings
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(2000) - et al.
Incentives versus standards: properties of accounting income in four East Asian countries
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(2003) The conservatism principle and the asymmetric timeliness of earnings
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(1997)- et al.
How does financial reporting quality relate to investment efficiency?
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(2009) - et al.
Earnings management to avoid earnings decreases and losses
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(1997) Managerial competition, information costs, and corporate governance: the use of accounting performance measures in proxy contests
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(1988)- et al.
Executive incentives and the horizon problem: an empirical investigation
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(1991) - et al.
Debt covenant violation and manipulation of accruals
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(1994) - et al.
The market pricing of accruals quality
Journal of Accounting and Economics
(2005)
The changing time series properties of earnings, cash flows and accruals: has financial reporting become more conservative?
Journal of Accounting and Economics
The economic implications of corporate financial reporting
Journal of Accounting and Economics
An unintended consequence of book-tax conformity: a loss of earnings informativeness
Journal of Accounting and Economics
The effect of bonus schemes on accounting decisions
Journal of Accounting and Economics
Accounting standards and value relevance of financial statements: an international analysis
Journal of Accounting and Economics
Opaque financial reports, R2, and crash risk
Journal of Financial Economics
Estimation and empirical properties of a firm-year measure of accounting conservatism
Journal of Accounting and Economics
Audit committee, board of director characteristics, and earnings management
Journal of Accounting and Economics
Performance matched discretionary accrual measures
Journal of Accounting and Economics
The implications of unverifiable fair-value accounting: evidence from the political economy of goodwill accounting
Journal of Accounting and Economics
Earnings management through real activities manipulation
Journal of Accounting and Economic
Debt-covenant violations and managers' accounting responses
Journal of Accounting and Economics
The contracting benefits from accounting conservatism to lenders and borrowers
Journal of Accounting and Economics
The effect of concern about reported income on discretionary spending decisions: the case of research and development
Accounting Review
The timing of asset sales and earnings manipulation
The Accounting Review
An empirical analysis of the relation between the board of director composition and financial statement fraud
The Accounting Review
Incentives and penalties related to earnings overstatements that violate GAAP
The Accounting Review
Convergent and discriminant validation by the multitrait–multimethod matrix
Psychological Bulletin
Audit partner tenure and audit quality
The Accounting Review
Real and accrual-based earnings management in the pre- and post-Sarbanes Oxley periods
Accounting Review
The quality of accruals and earnings: the role of accrual estimation errors
The Accounting Review
Cited by (121)
When and how are rule 10b5-1 plans used for insider stock sales?
2023, Journal of Financial EconomicsThe impact of terrorist attacks and mass shootings on earnings management
2023, British Accounting ReviewCorporate tax cuts, merger activity, and shareholder wealth
2021, Journal of Accounting and EconomicsAccounting for the middle: motivations, extent, and limitations of middle managers’ earnings management
2024, Journal of Business EconomicsFundamental performance and earnings quality in private firms
2024, International Journal of Accounting and Information Management
- ☆
I appreciate helpful comments from Michelle Hanlon (Editor), Mingyi Hung, Yaniv Konchitchki, Jeff McMullen and Karen Ton.